bizbuzzcontent

  • WHAT WE DO
  • WHO WE ARE
    • MEET THE TEAM
  • BLOG
  • CONTACT
You are here:   Home Blog Does Ghostwriting Make You a Fraud?

Does Ghostwriting Make You a Fraud?

July 6, 2015 by Jessica Lee 1 Comment

If you hire a ghostwriter, does that make you a fraud? What about if you are a ghostwriter – are you committing fraudulence in expertise?

I ran across a 2013 article from Demian Farnworth on the Raven blog on the brutally honest truth about ghostwriting, in which he chronicled his personal demise as a result of putting his “everything” into content that others were getting the credit for.

It struck a chord, of course, because if you’re hiring a company like mine, you’re hiring ghostwriters. In fact, I can’t think of any content service you’d hire where ghostwriting wasn’t a part of it, from in-depth articles to Web copy, e-books and beyond.

Whether you realize it or not, ghostwriting is a staple in many of the beloved speeches, screenplays, songs and other creative works we encounter daily. Calling ghostwriting unethical would mean you believe that some of the things you love are totally fraudulent — and that you’re not OK with that, either.

Heck, even some of the most well-known hip-hop artists, whose street cred is earned in part by their ability to rap, were made popular by others’ words.

Love Letters

There’s a Way to Go About It

Over at Forbes, one contributor discusses the ethics of ghostwriting, and argues that ghostwriting itself isn’t unethical, but claiming you don’t have a ghostwriter is.

While some industries have become very comfortable with the concept of ghostwriting, there are some circles within certain sectors that believe ghostwriting is a dirty word.

But there’s a way to go about it so it feels good for everyone involved; keeping in mind that it starts with the right mindset about what ghostwriting is.

Here’s how I see it: We’re providing a marketing service for brands and executives who need to be a part of the conversation; they have great ideas and experience to share, but no time to sit down and write them.

There is a process that goes along with this that ensures not only that the expert’s ideas are extracted effectively, but also that the brand is being upheld (whether personal or company).

It’s the way I’ve done it for years, and it’s how I’ve established the operational process at bizbuzzcontent. It all starts with a collaboration of ideas. And if the person/company is too busy to contribute even 15 minutes of their time to this collaboration, then a ghostwriter probably isn’t a good idea.

Woman on Laptop

I know I personally wouldn’t feel good about pouring my ideas and concepts into a piece of content that the other person – the bylined author – had no hand in creating.

This is the story that Demian chronicled at the Raven blog, and if I were on the other side of the service as the bylined author, I would feel somewhat fraudulent having my name on that piece, too.

Here at bizbuzzcontent, we’ve been in situations where we were asked to stretch a little further than usual to create ideas out of thin air, and the result was always that it inherently felt inauthentic.

My primary goal is to ensure our clients shine by showcasing their ideas, their expertise and their personality. Which brings me to another point: personality.

The Forbes article I linked to previously, discusses checkpoints for ethical ghostwriting, one of which is the following:

“Does the communicator use ghostwriters to make himself or herself appear to possess personal qualities that he or she does not really have? In other words, does the writer impart such qualities as eloquence, wit, coherence and incisive ideas to a communicator who otherwise possesses none of those traits? The ethicality decreases with the degree of the ‘stretch.”

This small detail is a key consideration with authenticity. We won’t manufacture stories, wit or perspective without the bylined author’s input. The bylined author needs to be solely responsible for infusing themself into the piece, whether through the review/editing process, direct conversations on the ideas/story leading up to the thing we’re writing about or whether it’s the ghostwriter picking up on the personality and conversational style of the bylined author over time.

What About When It’s Not Ethical?

A year or so ago, I got a phone call from a guy who said he ran a “content marketing” shop. He had somehow forged relationships with columnists at publications like Forbes online that would allow articles to be written under the columnist’s name, and promised to mention my clients’ products or services, and link to them from the article for a fee.

Red flag.

First. trading money for links is a no-no in Google’s book and can get your website into a lot of trouble. Even trading money for a mention seems grotesque — but maybe I’m being too conservative in my thinking there. Celebrities get paid to leverage their authority in the way of endorsements all the time, and we know damn well that [INSERT CELEB NAME] is not using [PRODUCT TYPE] at home.

Truth is, in a world where so much is driven by dollars and exposure, it’s hard to know where opportunity ends and sleaziness begins.

Apparently, Forbes may be aware that this or some form of this is happening, as the article I linked to prior points out that “in the case of the Forbes Contributor community, ghostwriting is expressly and even contractually forbidden. In fact, the publishing interface periodically requires contributors to re-verify ‘the words on this page are my own content, my own words and my own opinions’ before they are allowed to press ‘send.’”

Writers Need Checks and Balances, Too

I remember when I was writing for Search Engine Watch as a contributing reporter. More and more, I was being assigned topics on paid search (aka online advertising, pay per click, etc.). As a reporter, I could easily write about almost any topic in digital marketing because I have direct experience in the online marketing industry so I understand the issues being discussed.

But that doesn’t mean I have experience in online advertising specifically. Nevertheless, I was increasingly solicited to speak at conference events and comment in publications on matters related to online advertising the more I wrote about the topic for Search Engine Watch.

My skills and experience were greatly confused, even though my byline went to an author page that discussed my background, my company and what we did. I wasn’t a contributing expert to Search Engine Watch on the topic of online advertising; Search Engine Watch was a client of mine that hired me for my reporting services.

There’s a fine line that needs to be drawn by the ghostwriter if they are concerned about ethics, too. Some ghostwriters might jump on opportunities like those I just described to put themselves into the spotlight as an expert, and eventually claim to be practitioners in something after they’ve written and researched a topic over time.

Man Speaking into Can

Sure, anyone can be self-taught and become a practitioner in something, but it’s not until you have — what do they say? 10,000 hours actually practicing something that you are an expert? (Of course, others refute this).

In my opinion, just because we do something that could be a distant cousin to a high-demand skill set, doesn’t necessarily make us qualified to do that high-demand job. As ghostwriters, sometimes you retain information and other times you are simply a conduit.

Closing Thoughts

Probably one of the most valuable pieces of advice I can give to other ghostwriters is to put as much heart and soul into your own writing as you do for your clients, or else you can end up getting burnt out, fed up and questioning your services.

And for those who hire ghostwriters, expect to put in the collaboration time. Yes, you’re busy, but it’s the only way to ensure a level of authenticity for yourself and your company’s brand. The small investment in time will save you significant hours of writing and pay dividends to your marketing strategy.

Jessica Lee
Jessica Lee is founder and chief creative at bizbuzzcontent Inc., helping B2B and B2C businesses realize the value of quality web content to their marketing plans. Sign up for tips on content strategy and writing delivered to your inbox directly from Jessica and the bizbuzzcontent team.

Share this:

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Pinterest
  • Email

Filed Under: Writing

Comments

  1. Natalie says

    December 20, 2016 at 11:11 am

    Great article, Jessica!
    As a brand that considers ourselves “Power Publishers,” this article struck a chord with the foundation we have built ourselves upon. Although we don’t use ghostwriters, it doesn’t mean that some of the points you made above aren’t still applicable to the writers we have here. Yes, we would love to spit fire article after article, but we also know that we must be meticulous with the content we produce.

    We’d love to take a look at the articles we’ve created thus far and see what you think! https://www.powerpost.digital/insights/

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Testimonials

Professional content agency

Jessica leads one of the most professional content agencies I’ve ever worked with. We target a very niche industry, and Jessica and her team were very thoughtful in their approach. From planning thoughtful pieces, to researching and interviewing SMEs, to brainstorming promotion strategies, Jessica and her team maintain a high degree of professionalism and efficiency.

Steven S., Senior Manager, Demand Generation, Rentlytics

bizbuzzcontent
2018-07-31T17:22:53-04:00

Steven S., Senior Manager, Demand Generation, Rentlytics

Jessica leads one of the most professional content agencies I’ve ever worked with. We target a very niche industry, and Jessica and her team were very thoughtful in their approach. From planning thoughtful pieces, to researching and interviewing SMEs, to brainstorming promotion strategies, Jessica and her team maintain a high degree of professionalism and efficiency.
https://www.bizbuzzcontent.com/blog/testimonials/professional-content-agency/

Tailor-made content strategies

Jessica dedicated her time as a pro-bono volunteer with VolunteerMatch to help us with some key content marketing needs. What impressed me most about working with Jessica was the way she tailored her approach to accommodate the needs of our nonprofit with the resource constraints of our team. Jessica developed personas, one-pagers, case studies and website content that has resulted in an increase in traffic to our site and improved our ability to communicate to our key audiences.

Bree v.F., Director of Marketing and Engagement, VolunteerMatch

bizbuzzcontent
2018-07-31T17:22:20-04:00

Bree v.F., Director of Marketing and Engagement, VolunteerMatch

Jessica dedicated her time as a pro-bono volunteer with VolunteerMatch to help us with some key content marketing needs. What impressed me most about working with Jessica was the way she tailored her approach to accommodate the needs of our nonprofit with the resource constraints of our team. Jessica developed personas, one-pagers, case studies and website content that has resulted in an increase in traffic to our site and improved our ability to communicate to our key audiences.
https://www.bizbuzzcontent.com/blog/testimonials/tailor-made-content-strategies/

Highly targeted and relevant content

I've worked with Jessica at her company bizbuzzcontent for years. It's my go-to provider whenever my team is looking for high-quality content. What differentiates bizbuzzcontent is that they not only have superior writing skills but a rare ability to completely understand our industry, our company positioning, brand voice and tone, and customers. This just makes the content highly targeted and relevant, and goes a long way in achieving our marketing goals.

Nag P., Sr. Manager, Product Marketing, Salesforce

bizbuzzcontent
2018-07-31T17:22:31-04:00

Nag P., Sr. Manager, Product Marketing, Salesforce

I've worked with Jessica at her company bizbuzzcontent for years. It's my go-to provider whenever my team is looking for high-quality content. What differentiates bizbuzzcontent is that they not only have superior writing skills but a rare ability to completely understand our industry, our company positioning, brand voice and tone, and customers. This just makes the content highly targeted and relevant, and goes a long way in achieving our marketing goals.
https://www.bizbuzzcontent.com/blog/testimonials/highly-targeted-and-relevant-content/

Compelling content that drives results

I love Jessica and the team over at bizbuzzcontent. Within just a matter of a few interactions, she was able to understand, in depth, our complex solution and business model. Since then, she's been critical to us in driving compelling, engaging content via our blogs and white papers. She's a wonderful, thoughtful person to work with, and the work she's done has been a key factor in increasing our conversion rates.

Collin S., Angel Investor and Technology Executive

bizbuzzcontent
2018-07-31T17:22:41-04:00

Collin S., Angel Investor and Technology Executive

I love Jessica and the team over at bizbuzzcontent. Within just a matter of a few interactions, she was able to understand, in depth, our complex solution and business model. Since then, she's been critical to us in driving compelling, engaging content via our blogs and white papers. She's a wonderful, thoughtful person to work with, and the work she's done has been a key factor in increasing our conversion rates.
https://www.bizbuzzcontent.com/blog/testimonials/compelling-content-that-drives-results/

Outstanding process

bizbuzzcontent helps me efficiently leverage my own subject-matter expertise to create original content on timely topics. Together, we are able to distill complex topics into client-friendly articles that I can use across multiple platforms. I especially appreciate bizzbuzz’s super-efficient process because it keeps me on track for timely production of new content. Jessica Lee is a pleasure to work with, and I rely on her to bring a strategic eye to my publication efforts.

Priya H., Partner, Woodruff-Sawyer & Co.

bizbuzzcontent
2018-07-31T17:23:04-04:00

Priya H., Partner, Woodruff-Sawyer & Co.

bizbuzzcontent helps me efficiently leverage my own subject-matter expertise to create original content on timely topics. Together, we are able to distill complex topics into client-friendly articles that I can use across multiple platforms. I especially appreciate bizzbuzz’s super-efficient process because it keeps me on track for timely production of new content. Jessica Lee is a pleasure to work with, and I rely on her to bring a strategic eye to my publication efforts.
https://www.bizbuzzcontent.com/blog/testimonials/outstanding-process/

Strong content values

Jessica is a great content creator, writer, reporter and partner to work with. Highly articulate with strong content values and work ethos, Jessica adds great value to all projects she works on. I would happily recommend Jessica to people who wish to scale their content marketing efforts.

Andy B., C-Level Marketing and Strategy Consultant

bizbuzzcontent
2018-07-31T17:23:14-04:00

Andy B., C-Level Marketing and Strategy Consultant

Jessica is a great content creator, writer, reporter and partner to work with. Highly articulate with strong content values and work ethos, Jessica adds great value to all projects she works on. I would happily recommend Jessica to people who wish to scale their content marketing efforts.
https://www.bizbuzzcontent.com/blog/testimonials/strong-content-values-highly-recommended/

Added value

Jessica is a guest speaker of Microsoft internal training program. She made an awesome presentation of how to create marketable web ages to Microsoft Bing Ads product team and services team. Attendees found Jessica very engaging during the presentation. Microsoft Bing Ads is eager to apply the learning in our daily works, and look forward to partnering with Jessica to bring more value to digital advertising community.

Ping J., Product Manager, Microsoft Bing Ads

bizbuzzcontent
2018-07-31T17:21:44-04:00

Ping J., Product Manager, Microsoft Bing Ads

Jessica is a guest speaker of Microsoft internal training program. She made an awesome presentation of how to create marketable web ages to Microsoft Bing Ads product team and services team. Attendees found Jessica very engaging during the presentation. Microsoft Bing Ads is eager to apply the learning in our daily works, and look forward to partnering with Jessica to bring more value to digital advertising community.
https://www.bizbuzzcontent.com/blog/testimonials/added-value/

Critical extension of the marketing team

Jessica has been instrumental in building our content strategy from ground up, educating our stakeholders and increasing our exposure across all lines of insurance. I can say with confidence that she has been a critical extension of the marketing team, always producing timely deliverable. She has always been enthusiastic about creating new formats for us and new vehicles of information to help the marketing team raise awareness and drive internal adoption. Her most impressive feat from my perspective is how quickly and seamlessly she dived into our 12 lines of insurance. The dexterity and the level of expertise she demonstrated although she had never worked with insurance B2B client was absolutely incredible.

Stephanie M., VP Marketing Communications, Woodruff-Sawyer & Co.

bizbuzzcontent
2018-07-31T17:21:33-04:00

Stephanie M., VP Marketing Communications, Woodruff-Sawyer & Co.

Jessica has been instrumental in building our content strategy from ground up, educating our stakeholders and increasing our exposure across all lines of insurance. I can say with confidence that she has been a critical extension of the marketing team, always producing timely deliverable. She has always been enthusiastic about creating new formats for us and new vehicles of information to help the marketing team raise awareness and drive internal adoption. Her most impressive feat from my perspective is how quickly and seamlessly she dived into our 12 lines of insurance. The dexterity and the level of expertise she demonstrated although she had never worked with insurance B2B client was absolutely incredible.
https://www.bizbuzzcontent.com/blog/testimonials/critical-extension-of-the-marketing-team/

Excellent content program

We can't imagine how we managed without bizbuzzcontent before! Working with Jessica Lee is a dream. She is very creative and understands new concepts quickly. The content creation process at bizbuzzcontent is the most efficient we have come across in our many years of working with other writers and agencies. If you want an excellent content program and a company that goes above and beyond, hire bizbuzzcontent today!

Pauline J., CEO, Group Twenty Seven

bizbuzzcontent
2018-07-31T17:21:10-04:00

Pauline J., CEO, Group Twenty Seven

We can't imagine how we managed without bizbuzzcontent before! Working with Jessica Lee is a dream. She is very creative and understands new concepts quickly. The content creation process at bizbuzzcontent is the most efficient we have come across in our many years of working with other writers and agencies. If you want an excellent content program and a company that goes above and beyond, hire bizbuzzcontent today!
https://www.bizbuzzcontent.com/blog/testimonials/excellent-content-program/

Trusted partner for years

Jessica and her team at bizbuzzcontent have been a trusted partner for years, and have helped us with our blog, web copy and email marketing, in addition to providing lots of guidance on other content projects. The team is able to quickly get up to speed on any content project's requirements and create quality content that's on target. Over the years, they've helped us educate, drive brand awareness and website traffic. I would definitely recommend bizbuzzcontent for content services.

Ashley G., Digital Ad Management, SearchForce

bizbuzzcontent
2018-07-31T17:18:31-04:00

Ashley G., Digital Ad Management, SearchForce

Jessica and her team at bizbuzzcontent have been a trusted partner for years, and have helped us with our blog, web copy and email marketing, in addition to providing lots of guidance on other content projects. The team is able to quickly get up to speed on any content project's requirements and create quality content that's on target. Over the years, they've helped us educate, drive brand awareness and website traffic. I would definitely recommend bizbuzzcontent for content services.
https://www.bizbuzzcontent.com/blog/testimonials/trusted-partner-for-years/
0
0
bizbuzzcontent

Recent Posts

  • How to Create Article Introductions That Do Their One and Only Job
  • B2B Content Marketing in 2019: The Audience Is King
  • How to Create Headlines That Make Your Readers Want More
  • Writing Advice from Six Famous Horror Authors
  • How to Create and Market an E-Book

Wordsmith LLC

Copyright © 2023   bizbuzzcontent   All rights reserved

Copyright © 2023 · Agency Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in